Theories of the Right of Secession: A Republican Analysis

Lluis Perez-Lozano

Theories of the Right of Secession: A Republican Analysis

Lluis Perez-Lozano

Abstract

Republican theorists have paid little attention to the normative problems of secession conflicts. So far, there is no such thing as a democratic republican theory of right of secession (TRS); nor any comprehensive analysis of current TRS has ever been undertaken from a democratic republican point of view. This article tries to fill this second gap as a first step in order to fill that first one. In doing so, it shows how secession conflicts pose threats for two core democratic republican values: freedom and inclusion. The threats are, concretely, those of exclusion, blackmailing minorities, arbitrary permanent majorities, and instability. The article also shows how, due to their respective pro-unionist or pro-secessionist biases, no current TRS seems to be able to handle those threats; and briefly outlines how a democratic republican TRS, based on a non-unilateralist logic, could be developed.

Keywords

ascriptivism; factions; plebiscitarianism; remedialism; republicanism; secession

Full Text:

PDF HTML

References

Bauböck, Rainer (2000). Why stay together? A pluralist approach to secession and federation. In Will Kymlicka and Wayne Norman (Eds.), Citizenship in diverse societies (pp. 366-394). Oxford University.

Bello Hutt, Donald (2018). Republicanism, deliberative democracy, and equality of access and deliberation, Theoria, 84(1), 83-111. https://doi.org/10.1111/theo.12138

Beran, Harry (1984). A liberal theory of secession. Political Studies, 32(1), 21-31. https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1467-9248.1984.tb00163.x

Birch, Anthony (1984). Another liberal theory of secession. Political Studies, 32(4), 596-602. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9248.1984.tb01548.x

Buchanan, Allen (1991). Secession. The morality of political divorce from Fort Sumter to Lithuania and Quebec. Westview.

Buchanan, Allen (2007). Justice, legitimacy, and self-determination. Moral foundations for international law. Oxford University.

Caminal, Miquel (2007). Una lectura republicana i federal de l'autodeterminació [A republican and federal reading of self-determination], Revista d'Estudis Autonòmics i Federals, 5, 11-38.

Catala, Amandine (2017). Secession and distributive justice. Philosophical Studies, 174(2), 529-552. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-016-0695-2

Fichte, Johann G. (1997). Reden an die deutsche Nation [Addresses to the German nation]. In Wilhelm G. Jacobs and Peter L. Oesterreich (Eds): Fichtes Werke in 2 Bänden. Band 2, 539-788. Deutscher Klassiker.

Klabbers, Jan (2006). The right to be taken seriously: Self-determination in international law. Human Rights Quarterly, 28, 186-206.

Margalit, Avishai and Raz, Joseph (1990). National self-determination. The Journal of Philosophy, 87(9), 439-461. https://doi.org/10.2307/2026968

McGarry, John and Moore, Margaret (2011). Secession and domination. In Aleksandar Pavkovic and Peter Radan (Eds.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Secession (pp. 427-438). Ashgate.

Miller, David (1995). On nationality. Oxford University.

Miller, David (2003). Liberalism and boundaries: a response to Allen Buchanan. In Allen Buchanan, and Margaret Moore (Eds.), States, nations, and borders. The ethics of making boundaries (pp. 262-272). Cambridge University.

Miller, David (2008). Republicanism, national identity, and Europe. In Cécile Laborde and John Maynor (Eds.), Republicanism and political theory (pp. 133-158). Blackwell Publishing.

Nielsen, Kai (1998). Liberal nationalism and secession. In Margaret Moore (Ed.), National self-determination and secession (pp. 103-133). Oxford University.

Norman, Wayne (1998). The ethics of secession as the regulation of secessionist politics. In Margaret Moore (Ed.), National self-determination and secession (pp. 34-61). Oxford University.

Norman, Wayne (2003). Domesticating secession. In Stephen Macedo and Allen Buchanan (Eds.), Secession and self-determination (pp. 193-237). New York University.

Norman, Wayne (2006). Negotiating nationalism. Nation-building, federalism, and secession in the multinational state. Oxford University.

Ovejero, Félix (2006). Contra cromagnon. Nacionalismo, ciudadanía, democracia [Against Cromagnon: Nationalism, Citizenship, Democracy]. Montesinos.

Ovejero, Félix (2011). La trama estéril. Izquierda y nacionalismo [The Futile Plot: Left-wing politics and Nationalism]. Montesinos.

Patten, Alan (2002). Democratic secession from a multinational state. Ethics, 112, 558-586.

Pavkovic, Aleksandar, and Radan, Peter (2007). Creating new states. Theory and practice of secession. Ashgate.

Pettit, Philip (1997). Republicanism. A theory of freedom and government. Oxford University.

Pettit, Philip (2012). On the people's terms. A republican theory and model of democracy. Cambridge University.

Philpott, Daniel (1998). Self-determination in practice. In Margaret Moore (Ed.), National self-determination and secession (pp. 79-102). Oxford University.

Renan, Ernest (1996). What is a nation? In Geoff Eley and Ronald G. Suny (Eds.), Becoming national. A reader (pp. 42-56). Oxford University.

Requejo, Ferran and Caminal, Miquel (2011). Liberal democracies, national pluralism and federalism. In Ferran Requejo and Miquel Caminal (Eds.), Political liberalism and plurinational democracies (pp. 1-10). Routledge.

Rokkan, Stein and Urwin, Derek W. (1983). Economy, territory, identity. Politics of West European peripheries. Sage.

Sanjaume-Calvet, Marc (2020). Moralism in theories of secession: a realist perspective. Nations and Nationalism, 26(2), 323-343.

Seymour, Michel (2007). Secession as a remedial right. Inquiry, 50(4), 395-423. https://doi.org/10.1080/00201740701491191

Sellers, Mortimer N.S. (2006). Republican principles in international law. Palgrave.

Sieyès, Emmanuel-Joseph (1982). Qu'est-ce que le Tiers Etat? [What is the third estate?] Quadrige/PUF.

Skinner, Quentin (2002). A third concept of liberty. Proceedings of the British Academy, 117, 237-268.

Sunstein, Cass (1988). Beyond the republican revival. The Yale Law Journal, 97, 1538-1576 and 1589-1590.

Weinstock, Daniel (2000). Towards a proceduralist theory of secession. Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence, 13, 251-264. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0841820900000424

Weinstock, Daniel (2001). Constitutionalizing the right to secede. The Journal of Political Philosophy, 9(2), 182-203. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9760.00124

Weinstock, Daniel and Nadeau, Christian (Eds.). (2004). Republicanism. History, theory, practice. Frank Cass Publishers.

Wellman, Christopher H. (1995). A theory of secession. The case for political self-determination. Cambridge University.

Wellman, Christopher H. (2005). A defense of secession and political self-determination, Philosophy and Public Affairs, 24(2), 142-171. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1088-4963.1995.tb00026.x

Young, Iris M. (2005). Self-determination as non-domination. Ethnicities, 5(2), 139-159. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F1468796805052112

Refbacks

There are currently no refbacks.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Username
Password
Remember me