A turning point in the concept of justice: from Adam Smith to John Stuart Mill

Estrella Trincado Aznar

Home > No 0 (2012): January-June: 75-96 > Trincado Aznar

A turning point in the concept of justice: from Adam Smith to John Stuart Mill

Estrella Trincado Aznar

Abstract

Classical economists, John Stuart Mill included, based their theories on Adam Smith’s system. At some point, they labelled it as a "utilitarian" theory. However, Smith was non-utilitarian, perhaps even anti-utilitarian. One of the most amazing differences between classical economics versus Smithian theory consists of their concept of justice. Classical economics were based on a utilitarian concept; Smith criticizes the concept of utilitarian justice. Utility being a subjective picture, classical economists find it more difficult to draw limits to state intervention than Smith does. This paper compares Smith’s and John Stuart Mill’s concept of justice when they make the case for land tenure. Mill admits that society cannot properly be said to owe anything to the poor. However, not arguing from 'abstract rights,' but from 'utility' understood in its largest sense, Mill defended the nationalization of land. Mill was unable to draw any limits to state intervention. Conversely, Smith defended that justice is not a utilitarian concept. In this case, limits to state intervention are more easily drawn.

Keywords

John Stuart Mill, Adam Smith, state intervention, land tenure, justice

Full Text:

PDF

References

Bagehot, Walter (1848), “Principles of Political Economy, with some of their applications to Social Philosophy. By J. S. Mill”. The Prospective Review, vol. IV, 16, pp. 460- 502.

Barber, William J. (1969), "James Mill and the Theory of Economic Policy in India", History of Political Economy, vol. 1, n.º 1 (primavera), pp. 85-100.

Cairnes, John E. (1874), Some Leading Principles of Political Economy newly Expounded, London, Macmillan and Co.

Ekelund, Robert B. y Hébert, Robert F. (1992), Historia de la Teoría Económica y de su Método, Madrid, McGraw-Hill.

Escamilla Castillo, Manuel (ed) (2004), John Stuart Mill y las fronteras del liberalismo, Granada, Universidad de Granada.

Jones, Richard (1831), An Essay on the Distribution of Wealth and on the Sources of Taxation, London, John Murray.

Kydd, Samuel [Alfred] (1857), The History of the Factory Movement From the Year, 1802, to the Enactment of the Ten Hours Bill in 1847, London, Simpkin, Marshall, and Co.

Levin, Michael (2004), Mill on Civilization and Barbarism, London y New York, Routledge.

Marx, Karl (1981a), "La nacionalización de la tierra" [The International Herald, 15.VI.1872], Obras Escogidas, vol. II, Moscú, Progreso, pp. 305-308.

Michelet, Jules (1845), History of France, from the Earliest Period to the Present Time, New York , Appleton.

Mill, James (1965) [1821], Elements of Political Economy, Nueva York, Augustus M. Kelley.

Mill, John Stuart (1985) [1836], "Guizot"s Lectures on European civilization", Essays on French History and Historians, ed. Robson, Toronto, University of Toronto Press.

Mill, John Stuart (1836), "Civilization", Essays on Politics and Culture, London, pp.45-76.

Mill, John Stuart [1848] (1909), Principles of Political Economy with some of their Applications to Social Philosophy, London, Longmans, Green and Co., ed. William J. Ashley, 7ª edición.

Mill, John Stuart (1869), "Thornton on Labour and Its Claims", Review on "On Labour, its Wrongful Claims and Rightful Dues, its Actual Present and Possible Future", by William Thomas Thornton", Part I, Fortnightly Review, (May), pp. 505-18; Part II, (June, 1869), pp. 680-700, reeditados en Debates and Dissertation (1875), pp. 25-85.

Mill, John Stuart (1870), "Programme of the Land Tenure Reform Association, with an Explanatory Statement by John Stuart Mill", en Mill, J.S., Collected Works, Vol. V, Toronto, Toronto University Press, pp. 687-695.

Mill, John Stuart (1873), Autobiography. London, Longmans, Green, Reader, and Dyer.

Mill, John Stuart (1879), "Chapters on Socialism", Fortnightly Review, February: 21737; March: 373-382; April: 513-530,

Collected Works of John Stuart Mill. Vol. V, Essays on Economics and Society, Toronto, University of Toronto Press, pp. 703-53

Mill, John Stuart (1986a), "Advice to Land Reformers" [Examiner, 4.I.], Collected Works. Vol.XXV: Newspaper Writings, December 1847-July 1873, Toronto, University of Toronto Press, [1873], pp. 1227-1231.

Mill, John Stuart (1986b), "Should Public Bodies Be Required to Sell Their Lands?" [Examiner, 11.I], Collected Works, Vol.XXV: Newspaper Writings, December 1847-July 1873, Toronto, University of Toronto Press,[1873], pp. 1232-1235.

Mill, John Stuart (1986c), "The Right to Property in Land" [Examiner, 19.VII.], Collected Works, Vol.XXV: Newspaper Writings, December 1847-July 1873, Toronto, University of Toronto Press, [1873], pp. 1235-1243.

Mill, John Stuart (1988a), "Land Tenure Reform Association. Report of the Inaugural Public Meeting Held at the Freemason´s Hall" [Londres, 15.V.], Collected Works, Vol. XXIX: Public and Parliamentary Speeches, July 1869-March 1873, J.M.Robson y B.L. Kinzer, eds., Toronto, Toronto University Press, [1871], pp. 416-424.

Mill, John Stuart (1988b), "Land Tenure Reform Association. Report of the Public Meeting held at Exeter Hall" [Londres, 18.III], Collected Works, Vol. XXIX: Public and Parliamentary Speeches, July 1869-March 1873, J.M.Robson y B.L. Kinzer, ed., Toronto, Toronto University Press, [1873], pp. 425-431.

Mill, John Stuart (1891), On Colonies and Colonization, 1848, From: John Stuart Mill, Principles of Political Economy, ed. J. Laurence Laughlin, New York, D. Appleton & Co., pp. 540-560.

Mill, John Stuart (1985) [1848], Principios de Economía Política FCE, México.

Morley, John (1881), The Life of Richard Cobden, 2 Vols., London, Chapman and Hall.

O’ Brien, Dennis P. (1989), Los economistas clásicos, Madrid, Alianza.

Proudhon, Pierre Joseph (1840), Qu`est-ce que la propieté?, París, E. Flammarion.

Ramos, José Luis (2004), "Mill, Marx y la "Land Tenure Reform Association": en torno a la política económica de la tierra", VV.AA., Josep Fontana. Història y Projecte Social, vol. I, Barcelona, Crítica, pp. 769-784.

Ricardo, David (1965), "Carta de D. Ricardo a James Mill del 18 de diciembre de 1821", Obras y correspondencia. Vol. IX: Cartas, julio 1821-23, México, FCE, pp. 91-97.

Mill, John Stuart (1973) [1817], Principios de economía política y tributación, Madrid, Seminarios y Ediciones.

Rima, Ingrid H. (1975), "James Mill and Classical Economics: A Reappraisal", Eastern Economic Journal, vol. 2, nº 2 (abril), pp. 113-118.

Rodríguez Braun, Carlos (1989), La cuestión colonial y la economía clásica, Madrid, Alianza.

Sismondi, Jean-Charles-Léonard (1827), Nouveaux principes d’économie politique, Paris, Calmann-Lévy, 1971.

Schwartz, Pedro (1968), La "Nueva Economía Política" de John Stuart Mill, Madrid, Tecnos.

Screpanti, Ernesto y Zamagni, Stefano (1997), Panorama de historia del pensamiento económico, Barcelona, Ariel.

Smith, Adam (1988), Investigación sobre la Naturaleza y Causas de la Riqueza de las Naciones, Vilassar de Mar (Barcelona), 2 vols, Oikus Tau.

Stephen, Leslie, Sir (1900), The English Utilitarians, New York, London, Edinburgh, G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 3 volúmenes.

The North American Review (1848), Review on "Mill`s Political Economy: Population and Property", vol 67, nº 141, pp 370-420 (University of Northern Iowa).

Thornton, William T. (1874) [1848], A Plea for Peasant Proprietors, with the Outlines of a Plan for their Establishment in Ireland, London, J. Murray and Co.

Trincado, Estrella (2003), "La escuela clásica (IV): John Stuart Mill", Historia del Pensamiento Económico, Madrid, Editorial Síntesis, pp. 201-229.

Trincado, Estrella (2004), "Equity, utility and transaction costs: On the origin of the judicial power in Adam Smith", Storia del Pensiero Economico,vol 1, issue of the new series, pp. 33-51

Trincado, Estrella (2006), "Adam Smith criticism of the doctrine of utility: a theory of the Creative Present", Montes, Leonidas y Schliesser, Eric, New Voices on Adam Smith, New York and London, Routledge, pp. 313-327.

Trincado, Estrella (2008), "John Stuart Mill: punto de inflexión entre los clásicos y los neoclásicos", Ruiz Resa, J. D. (ed), John Stuart Mill y la democracia del siglo XXI, Madrid, Dykinson.

Refbacks

There are currently no refbacks.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Las Torres de Lucca. Revista Internacional de Filosofía Política
ISSN-e

Username
Password
Remember me